Can you explain why stocks are getting hammered? What makes them so susceptible to downward movement in this market environment?
Based on the Russell indices, value investing outperformed growth investing for seven straight years (2000 through 2006). Financial stocks, such as banks, led the value indices (e.g., Russell 1000 Value) higher in the past several years. However, in my opinion, value stocks, such as GM, peaked when many low-quality value stocks led the overall stock market higher in 2006.
In 2007, growth stocks outperformed value stocks every month, and the financial stocks that dominate the value indices, such as banks, have “flamed out” due to the ongoing credit crisis in structured investment vehicles such as collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), structured investment vehicles (SIVs) and other instruments behind the subprime-fueled credit crisis.
Some big banks, like Bank of America (BAC) now have dividend yields in excess of 5%, so the selling in financial stocks is getting overdone, but due to the overhanging crisis in subprime mortgages, mortgage companies and other financial stocks have been hit very hard and may continue to be hit with relentless selling pressure as Wall Street shifts its focus away from value investing to growth investing as many strategists are predicting. I suspect that growth investing will outperform value investing for possibly two years or more.
Q&A Archive
- Video: How to Build a Resilient Portfolio
- Stocks: Buy this High Dividend Stock Now!
- Stock Insights: Best Stocks to Buy Now: Video Game Publishers
- Blog: Five Biggest Mistakes Investors are Making Right Now
- Glossary: What is earnings season?
- Market Analysis: Oil Speculators Scapegoats No More!
- eLetter: Earnings Season: Finding the Best Stocks to Buy on Wall Street.
- How to Invest: Investing for the Future Amid Bad News.
- Top Story: Crude Oil Prices Distract Investors
Subscribers log in below for complete portfolios, specific buy prices, up-to-the minute buy/sell/hold recommendations and more! Not a subscriber? Sign up risk-free today.
| Video Demo |
| Stock | Symbol | Grade | |
|---|---|---|---|
| BP PLC (ADS) | BP | B | BUY |
| Chevron Corp. | CVX | B | BUY |
| Exxon Mobil Co | XOM | C | HOLD |
| Hess Corp. | HES | A | BUY |
| PetroChina Co. | PTR | B | BUY |
| Sunoco Inc. | SUN | D | SELL |
| Tesoro Corp. | TSO | F | SELL |
| Stock | Symbol | Grade | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brinker Intern | EAT | C | HOLD |
| CBRL Group Inc | CBRL | D | SELL |
| Cheesecake Fac | CAKE | C | HOLD |
| DineEquity Inc | DIN | F | SELL |
| P.F. Chang's C | PFCB | C | HOLD |
| Ruby Tuesday I | RT | F | SELL |
| Ruth's Hospita | RUTH | F | SELL |







